Since I started this blog back in July 2014, I have been sharing and chronicling our financial independence journey. Many of the blog articles I have written since have been focusing on the accumulation phase – how to save money, how to increase your savings gap, how to pick stocks, how to invest, how to grow net worth, etc. It’s fun writing about the accumulation and seeing our dividend income and net worth grow. The fundamental theme has been that we’re building our dividend portfolio so we can live off dividends one day.
As we get closer to financial independence and early retirement, my writing has been slowly shifting toward the decumulation phase, or at least our plans and some of the intricate details for this new phase of our lives.
You probably have noticed I have been writing about and referencing building a cash reserve and building buffers, and levers in early retirement, as well as health care in retirement.
All these topics essentially expose a significant moment in any FIRE journey. You stop putting money in the portfolio. Instead, you’re pulling money out.
When you’re pulling money out and start withdrawing from your portfolio, you are now facing something called sequence of returns risk. This single factor is by far the biggest threat that determines if your money will last or if it will run out.
Sequence of returns risk is important in retirement and is even more important in early retirement. Therefore, I want to walk through what sequence of returns risk actually is, compare three scenarios using real historical data, and discuss what we are doing to minimize this risk.
What is sequence of returns risk?
If you never touch your portfolio and simply leave it alone for decades, it doesn’t matter what order the returns come in. Your portfolio value will end up exactly the same regardless of what the return sequences are. So a market that gains 10%, loses 30%, gains 15%, and so on for 30 years will end up the same regardless of the order. Compounding will just do its thing.
However, when you start withdrawing money from your portfolio, your portfolio’s annual return matters significantly. Every retiree dreads experiencing a significant market drop the year he/she retires while withdrawing 4% for living expenses.
All of a sudden, your portfolio value is smaller. If you need roughly the same dollar amount to sustain your living expenses the next year, you need to withdraw a higher percentage of your portfolio, which will lower your portfolio value even more. Furthermore, the initial drop in portfolio value due to a market drop means your portfolio now has less runway to recover, because there is less money left to compound.
On the other hand, if you encounter a bull market in the first few years of retirement, your portfolio value can grow so much that your withdrawals are barely making a dent. This is the ideal case. By the time the market drops, your portfolio is much higher and you end up with a solid cushion that doesn’t threaten your retirement plan.
In other words, your retirement success outcome heavily relies on the average return of the first five to ten years. The later years matter far less. As in many things, ‘timing is everything.”
The math behind sequence of returns risk
Don’t believe what I just stated above? Let me demonstrate with some actual numbers.
Let’s imagine we have two retirees, both of whom retire with a $1,000,000 portfolio, both withdrawing $40,000 per year plus adjusted up by 3% annually for inflation, both experience the exact same five annual returns, but in reverse order.
Retire A experiences -20%, -10%, +5%, +15%, and +30%
Retire B experiences +30%, +15%, +5%, -10%, and -20%
If neither retiree touches their portfolio (i.e. no withdrawals from selling of shares), then they’d both end up with roughly $1.13 million after five years.
Actual calculation:
| Retiree A | Retiree B | |||||
| Year | Starting value | Returns | End Value | Starting value | Returns | End Value |
| 1 | $ 1,000,000 | -20% | $ 800,000 | $ 1,000,000 | 30% | $ 1,300,000 |
| 2 | $ 800,000 | -10% | $ 720,000 | $ 1,300,000 | 15% | $ 1,495,000 |
| 3 | $ 720,000 | 5% | $ 756,000 | $ 1,495,000 | 5% | $ 1,569,750 |
| 4 | $ 756,000 | 15% | $ 869,400 | $ 1,569,750 | -10% | $ 1,412,775 |
| 5 | $ 869,400 | 30% | $ 1,130,220 | $ 1,412,775 | -20% | $ 1,130,220 |
But when retirees withdraw from their portfolio, they end up with different annual returns by the end of five years.
Retiree A ($1M start, $40k withdrawal, 3% inflation adjustment each year):
- Year 1: withdraw $40,000 -> -20% return -> $768,000
- Year 2: withdraw $41,200 -> -10% return -> $654,120
- Year 3: withdraw $42,436 -> +5% return -> $642,268
- Year 4: withdraw $43,709 -> +15% return -> $688,343
- Year 5: withdraw $45,020 -> +30% -> $836,319
Retiree B ($1M start, $40k withdrawal, 3% inflation adjustment each year, reversed returns):
- Year 1: withdraw $40,000 -> +30% return -> $1,248,000
- Year 2: withdraw $41,200 -> +15% return -> $1,387,820
- Year 3: withdraw $42,436 -> +5% return -> $1,412,653
- Year 4: withdraw $43,709 -> -10% return -> $1,232,050
- Year 5: withdraw $45,020 -> -15% -> $949,623
A difference of $113k! If the retirees started with a larger portfolio, the difference would be even bigger.
What exactly happened?
Well, Retiree A got hammered by two years of poor performance when he/she first retired, so the withdrawals of $40k and $41.2k caused a huge dent in his/her portfolio. For Retiree B, the two awesome years of performance initially, then an OK year before encountering two bad years and we can see the withdrawals didn’t reduce the portfolio value significantly.
Sequence of returns – 2000, 2008, and 2020 scenarios
I thought it would be more interesting to have three different retirement scenarios using TSX historical returns.
Imagine we have three retirees, each starting with a $2 million portfolio, withdrawing $80k in year 1, and increasing the withdrawal by 3% each year to account for inflation.
For simplicity’s sake, let’s assume all three hold 100% Canadian equity. I used the TSX annual returns and calculated the yearly returns by including an approximate dividend yield, so the annual returns you see below are slightly higher than the pure price index returns.
For all three scenarios, I ran the calculation until the end of 2025.
Scenario 1 – Retirement in January 2000 (the dot-com bust)
| Year | Start Value | Withdrawal | Return | End Value |
| 2000 | $2,000,000 | $80,000 | 7.40% | $2,062,080 |
| 2001 | $2,062,080 | $82,400 | −12.6% | $1,730,240 |
| 2002 | $1,730,240 | $84,872 | −12.4% | $1,441,343 |
| 2003 | $1,441,343 | $87,418 | 26.70% | $1,715,422 |
| 2004 | $1,715,422 | $90,041 | 14.50% | $1,861,062 |
| 2005 | $1,861,062 | $92,742 | 24.10% | $2,194,485 |
| 2006 | $2,194,485 | $95,524 | 17.30% | $2,462,081 |
| 2007 | $2,462,081 | $98,390 | 9.80% | $2,595,333 |
| 2008 | $2,595,333 | $101,342 | −33.0% | $1,670,974 |
| 2009 | $1,670,974 | $104,382 | 35.10% | $2,116,466 |
| 2010 | $2,116,466 | $107,513 | 17.60% | $2,362,529 |
| 2011 | $2,362,529 | $110,739 | −8.7% | $2,055,884 |
| 2012 | $2,055,884 | $114,061 | 7.20% | $2,081,635 |
| 2013 | $2,081,635 | $117,483 | 13.00% | $2,219,492 |
| 2014 | $2,219,492 | $121,007 | 10.60% | $2,320,924 |
| 2015 | $2,320,924 | $124,637 | −8.3% | $2,013,995 |
| 2016 | $2,013,995 | $128,377 | 21.10% | $2,283,484 |
| 2017 | $2,283,484 | $132,228 | 9.10% | $2,347,020 |
| 2018 | $2,347,020 | $136,195 | −8.9% | $2,014,062 |
| 2019 | $2,014,062 | $140,280 | 22.90% | $2,302,878 |
| 2020 | $2,302,878 | $144,489 | 5.60% | $2,279,259 |
| 2021 | $2,279,259 | $148,824 | 25.10% | $2,665,174 |
| 2022 | $2,665,174 | $153,288 | −5.8% | $2,366,197 |
| 2023 | $2,366,197 | $157,887 | 11.80% | $2,468,890 |
| 2024 | $2,468,890 | $162,624 | 21.60% | $2,804,420 |
| 2025 | $2,804,420 | $167,502 | 19.60% | $3,153,754 |
For this retiree, the portfolio started at $2M and dropped to as low as $1.44M in 2002. The portfolio took another beating in 2008 during the financial crisis, dropping to a low of $1.67M, but eventually recovered and ended 2025 at $2.8M.
What’s amazing is that after 26 years and withdrawing $3.084M, the portfolio ended up higher than it started. Now, if we consider inflation and adjust the portfolio value accordingly, yes, the retiree is a bit worse off than when he/she started. But the important part is that he/she didn’t run out of money.
Because the three bear markets were spread out, there was sufficient time for this retiree’s portfolio to recover.
It’s important to note that a bad early sequence is survivable if the bear market is spread out across multiple years (-12.6% in 2001 and -12.4% in 2002 instead of more than -20% in one year alone). Furthermore, because the retiree didn’t panic sell, the portfolio was able to recover over time.
Scenario 2 – Retirement in January 2008 (the global financial crisis)
| Year | Start Value | Withdrawal | Return | End Value |
| 2008 | $2,000,000 | $80,000 | −33.0% | $1,286,400 |
| 2009 | $1,286,400 | $82,400 | 35.10% | $1,626,604 |
| 2010 | $1,626,604 | $84,872 | 17.60% | $1,813,077 |
| 2011 | $1,813,077 | $87,418 | −8.7% | $1,575,526 |
| 2012 | $1,575,526 | $90,041 | 7.20% | $1,592,441 |
| 2013 | $1,592,441 | $92,742 | 13.00% | $1,694,660 |
| 2014 | $1,694,660 | $95,524 | 10.60% | $1,768,644 |
| 2015 | $1,768,644 | $98,390 | −8.3% | $1,531,623 |
| 2016 | $1,531,623 | $101,342 | 21.10% | $1,732,070 |
| 2017 | $1,732,070 | $104,382 | 9.10% | $1,775,808 |
| 2018 | $1,775,808 | $107,513 | −8.9% | $1,519,817 |
| 2019 | $1,519,817 | $110,739 | 22.90% | $1,731,757 |
| 2020 | $1,731,757 | $114,061 | 5.60% | $1,708,287 |
| 2021 | $1,708,287 | $117,483 | 25.10% | $1,990,096 |
| 2022 | $1,990,096 | $121,007 | −5.8% | $1,760,682 |
| 2023 | $1,760,682 | $124,637 | 11.80% | $1,829,098 |
| 2024 | $1,829,098 | $128,377 | 21.60% | $2,068,077 |
| 2025 | $2,068,077 | $132,228 | 19.60% | $2,315,275 |
In Scenario 2, the -33% in year 1 of retirement caused havoc to the portfolio value as the portfolio went from $2M to below $1.3M, a drop of over $700k. What’s interesting is that even after 10 years, at the end of 2017, the portfolio value was at $1.78M, well below the starting value of $2M.
Even after 14 years, at the end of 2021, the portfolio value was still at $1.99M, still below $2M, in nominal dollars. This is despite this retiree encountering one of the strongest post-crisis bull markets in modern history (+25.10% return).
The good news is that this retiree ended up with a $2.3M portfolio at the end of 2025. He/she didn’t run out of money despite having withdrawn over $1.87M from the portfolio.
This is why it was so brutal to have retired during the financial crisis and a perfect example of why sequence of return risk is so important in retirement. One massive bad year in the first year of retirement can reshape your retirement plan completely.
Scenario 3 – Retire in January 2020 (COVID-19 global pandemic)
| Year | Start Value | Withdrawal | Return | End Value |
| 2020 | $2,000,000 | $80,000 | 5.60% | $2,027,520 |
| 2021 | $2,027,520 | $82,400 | 25.10% | $2,433,345 |
| 2022 | $2,433,345 | $84,872 | −5.8% | $2,212,262 |
| 2023 | $2,212,262 | $87,418 | 11.80% | $2,375,575 |
| 2024 | $2,375,575 | $90,041 | 21.60% | $2,779,210 |
| 2025 | $2,779,210 | $92,742 | 19.60% | $3,213,016 |
The market was down significantly in March 2020 due to the COVID-19 global pandemic, but it recovered extremely quickly compared to other bear markets in the past. This retiree ended up with over $3.2M at the end of 2025. The -5.8% downturn in 2022 was a small blip because the portfolio had already built a cushion.
To summarize, at the end of 2025:
- Scenario 1 Retiree: $3.15M (26 years in, $3.084M total withdrawn)
- Scenario 2 Retiree: $2.32M (18 years in, $1.87M total withdrawn)
- Scenario 3 Retiree: $3.21M (6 years in, $517k total withdrawn)
What if we only look at five years after retirement for these three scenarios? This would be more of an apples-to-apples comparison since they all started with the same portfolio value with identical yearly withdrawal amounts.
After 5 years of retirement:
- Scenario 1 Retiree – $1.86M (end of 2004, +4.7% annualized return)
- Scenario 2 Retiree – $1.59M (end of 2012, +3.6% annualized return)
- Scenario 3 Retiree – $2.78M (end of 2024, +11.7% annualized return)
Some interesting things to point out:
- When we run FIRE spreadsheets and simulations, many of us just assume a steady yearly return (like 7%). This is a very naive view because we aren’t accounting for different return sequences. Therefore, I think the simulations need to allow for variable annual returns.
- The 2000 retiree (Scenario 1) encountered both the dot-com bust and the global financial crisis but ended up in better shape than the 2008 retiree (Scenario 2). This seems counterintuitive because the 2000 retiree encountered two bear markets while the 2008 retiree only encountered one. The key difference is that the 2000 retiree’s early losses were spread across three years (2000-2002) instead of concentrated in a single year (-33% in 2008). A significant market drop in year 1 of retirement is far more damaging than the same total loss spread across multiple years.
What if retirees use a fixed 4% portfolio withdrawal amount?
In the three scenarios above, we started with an $80k withdrawal, 4% of the $2M portfolio. Each year, the withdrawal amount is increased by 3% to account for inflation regardless of the value of the portfolio.
What happens if the retirees use a dynamic withdrawal amount by only withdrawing 4% of the year-end portfolio value?
Scenario 1 – Retirement in January 2000 (the dot-com bust)
| Year | Start Value | Withdrawal | Return | End Value |
| 2000 | $2,000,000 | $80,000 | 7.4% | $ 2,062,080.00 |
| 2001 | $2,062,080 | $82,483 | -12.6% | $ 1,730,167.60 |
| 2002 | $1,730,168 | $69,207 | -12.4% | $ 1,455,001.75 |
| 2003 | $1,455,002 | $58,200 | 26.7% | $ 1,769,747.73 |
| 2004 | $1,769,748 | $70,790 | 14.5% | $ 1,945,306.70 |
| 2005 | $1,945,307 | $77,812 | 24.1% | $ 2,317,560.59 |
| 2006 | $2,317,561 | $92,702 | 17.3% | $ 2,609,758.63 |
| 2007 | $2,609,759 | $104,390 | 9.8% | $ 2,750,894.38 |
| 2008 | $2,750,894 | $110,036 | -33.0% | $ 1,769,375.26 |
| 2009 | $1,769,375 | $70,775 | 35.1% | $ 2,294,808.94 |
| 2010 | $2,294,809 | $91,792 | 17.6% | $ 2,590,747.50 |
| 2011 | $2,590,748 | $103,630 | -8.7% | $ 2,270,738.37 |
| 2012 | $2,270,738 | $90,830 | 7.2% | $ 2,336,862.27 |
| 2013 | $2,336,862 | $93,474 | 13.0% | $ 2,535,028.19 |
| 2014 | $2,535,028 | $101,401 | 10.6% | $ 2,691,591.53 |
| 2015 | $2,691,592 | $107,664 | -8.3% | $ 2,369,461.86 |
| 2016 | $2,369,462 | $94,778 | 21.1% | $ 2,754,641.58 |
| 2017 | $2,754,642 | $110,186 | 9.1% | $ 2,885,101.40 |
| 2018 | $2,885,101 | $115,404 | -8.9% | $ 2,523,194.28 |
| 2019 | $2,523,194 | $100,928 | 22.9% | $ 2,976,965.54 |
| 2020 | $2,976,966 | $119,079 | 5.6% | $ 3,017,928.59 |
| 2021 | $3,017,929 | $120,717 | 25.1% | $ 3,624,411.52 |
| 2022 | $3,624,412 | $144,976 | -5.8% | $ 3,277,627.82 |
| 2023 | $3,277,628 | $131,105 | 11.8% | $ 3,517,812.39 |
| 2024 | $3,517,812 | $140,712 | 21.6% | $ 4,106,553.47 |
| 2025 | $4,106,553 | $164,262 | 19.6% | $ 4,714,980.44 |
Scenario 2 – Retirement in January 2008 (the global financial crisis)
| Year | Start Value | Withdrawal | Return | End Value |
| 2008 | $2,000,000 | $80,000 | -33.0% | $ 1,286,400.00 |
| 2009 | $ 1,286,400 | $51,456 | 35.1% | $ 1,668,409.34 |
| 2010 | $ 1,668,409 | $66,736 | 17.6% | $ 1,883,567.41 |
| 2011 | $ 1,883,567 | $75,343 | -8.7% | $ 1,650,909.17 |
| 2012 | $ 1,650,909 | $66,036 | 7.2% | $ 1,698,983.64 |
| 2013 | $ 1,698,984 | $67,959 | 13.0% | $ 1,843,057.45 |
| 2014 | $ 1,843,057 | $73,722 | 10.6% | $ 1,956,884.68 |
| 2015 | $ 1,956,885 | $78,275 | -8.3% | $ 1,722,684.72 |
| 2016 | $ 1,722,685 | $68,907 | 21.1% | $ 2,002,724.35 |
| 2017 | $ 2,002,724 | $80,109 | 9.1% | $ 2,097,573.38 |
| 2018 | $ 2,097,573 | $83,903 | -8.9% | $ 1,834,453.77 |
| 2019 | $ 1,834,454 | $73,378 | 22.9% | $ 2,164,361.94 |
| 2020 | $ 2,164,362 | $86,574 | 5.6% | $ 2,194,143.56 |
| 2021 | $ 2,194,144 | $87,766 | 25.1% | $ 2,635,078.65 |
| 2022 | $ 2,635,079 | $105,403 | -5.8% | $ 2,382,954.32 |
| 2023 | $ 2,382,954 | $95,318 | 11.8% | $ 2,557,577.22 |
| 2024 | $ 2,557,577 | $102,303 | 21.6% | $ 2,985,613.34 |
| 2025 | $ 2,985,613 | $119,425 | 19.6% | $ 3,427,961.81 |
Scenario 3 – Retire in January 2020 (COVID-19 global pandemic)
| Year | Start Value | Withdrawal | Return | End Value |
| 2020 | $2,000,000 | $80,000 | 5.60% | $ 2,027,520.00 |
| 2021 | $ 2,027,520 | $81,101 | 25.10% | $ 2,434,970.42 |
| 2022 | $ 2,434,970 | $97,399 | -5.80% | $ 2,201,992.45 |
| 2023 | $ 2,201,992 | $88,080 | 11.80% | $ 2,363,354.46 |
| 2024 | $ 2,363,354 | $94,534 | 21.60% | $ 2,758,885.46 |
| 2025 | $ 2,758,885 | $110,355 | 19.60% | $ 3,167,641.93 |
That’s interesting, isn’t it? All three retirees end up with way more money than they started. What caught my eye in particular when using different withdrawal methods:
- Scenario 1: 2002, $1.441M vs. $1.455M
- Scenario 2: 2011, $1.575M vs. $1.65M
- Scenario 3: 2022, $2.212M vs. $2.201M
The 4% withdrawal of the end-of-year portfolio value means that in bad years, you tighten your belt by withdrawing less, but in good years, you can spend more by withdrawing more.
The real question is whether the retirees can have a good quality of life with a lower withdrawal amount. For example, in Scenario 1, the retiree could only withdraw $58.2K to spend in 2003 and in Scenario 2, the retiree could only withdraw $51.4k to spend in 2009. Not a lot of money in either case…
Why early retirees (aka FIRE folks) face sequence of returns risk worse than traditional retirees
FIRE folks who seek early retirement face exponentially higher sequence of returns risk compared to traditional retirees.
Why?
First, the withdrawal period is much longer. Someone who retires at the traditional retirement age of 65 may only have a 20 to 30 years of time horizon; someone who retires at 45 has a 40 to 50 years of time horizon!
Therefore, a bad early sequence of returns is far more damaging to early retirees, despite the fact that they would have more time to compound. Earlier this year, Morningstar suggested a safe withdrawal rate closer to 3.9% for a 30-year retirement. For a longer retirement, most research suggests a more conservative withdrawal rate of 3.0% to 3.5%.
Here in Canada, you can use CPP and OAS to supplement your retirement income starting at 65. (Or even 60 in the case of CPP, with the 36% penalty).Having CPP and OAS available reduces sequence of returns risk because part of the income is independent of your investment portfolio performance. However, for someone who retires at 45, your investment portfolio needs to sustain you for 20 years before you can receive CPP and OAS.
The first five to ten years are when you’re most sensitive to the sequence of returns risk. So having to depend 100% of your income on your investment portfolio will increase the overall risk.
One key advantage early retirees have compared to traditional retirees is that when you’re in your 40s or 50s, you are probably not completely “retired.” You probably are making money somehow, either from a part-time job or a hobby. So you aren’t completely “living off” your portfolio. Furthermore, early retirees have the option to go back to a full-time job, because they still have substantial human capital.
What can you do to minimize sequence of returns risk?
So sequence of returns risk is very real and is definitely something retirees should consider in their retirement planning. Having said that, I believe there are a few strategies you can use to minimize such risk.
1. Keep a cash buffer
This is what I have been writing a lot lately. The simplest hedge against sequence of returns risk is having enough cash set aside so you don’t have to touch or be forced to withdraw from your investment portfolio in down-market years.
A cash buffer of 1 year’s expenses is good, but it depends on your risk tolerance and how you are funding your retirement. For some, you may want to have a cash buffer enough for two to five years of annual expenses (yes, I know five years is a lot of cash sitting around and you incur opportunity cost).
Essentially, keeping a cash buffer allows you to draw from the buffer when the markets are down so you can wait and let the investment portfolio recover. On the other hand, when the markets are up, you can withdraw from the portfolio to refill the buffer.
For my own curiosity, I ran a few different scenarios using the worst case (retired in 2008).
- Retired with a $2M portfolio and a $160k cash buffer (i.e. 2 years of expenses). Cash earned 2% interest rate.
- Scenario 1: a simple buffer where the retiree would withdraw from the cash pile if the market returned negative that year.
- Scenario 2: dynamic cash buffer. Retiree would withdraw from the cash pile if the market returned negative that year. If not enough cash, the retiree would draw 65% from the cash pile and 35% from the portfolio. Whenever the market returned >15%, the retiree would withdraw additional funds to top up the cash pile by $20k
- Scenario 3: dynamic cash buffer again but 60% cash and 40% portfolio composition if not sufficient cash was available in a bad market year. In good years, top up the cash pile by $40k
Running the numbers, this is what I found:
| Strategy | Portfolio | Cash | Combined |
| No buffer | $2,315,275 | — | $2,315,275 |
| Simple $160k buffer | $2,601,175 | $114,260 | $2,715,435 |
| Dynamic: $20k refill, 65/35 | $2,733,921 | $41,208 | $2,775,129 |
| Dynamic: $40k refill, 60/40 | $2,540,897 | $101,242 | $2,642,139 |
As you can see from above, the $20k refill, 65/35 came out ahead and had the least cash drag. Meanwhile, the $40k refill, 60/40 seemed to have the most cash drag.
The important point here is that at the end of 2025, the retiree came out ahead by having a cash pile. The clear pattern I noticed is that the more aggressively the retiree pulls money into the cash buffer, the safer the individual down year feels. But this lowers your long run wealth. Because the cash pile only earns a 2% interest, which is a drag compared to leaving money invested in a market and let it compound.
Keeping a cash pile in retirement will definitely allow you to sleep better at night!
2. Utilize bonds and build a bond tent
In theory, bond prices have an opposite relationship to equities. So when equities go down, bonds are supposed to go up (although that is not ALWAYS the case, theory).The inverse relationship allows retirees to protect themselves during market downturns by holding different percentages of equities and bonds in their portfolios.
The bond tent idea is popularized by Michel Kitces. The idea involves gradually increasing your bond allocation in the five years leading up to retirement, then gradually reducing it back down by year 10 or 15 of retirement. At the height of the bond tent, you’d aim to have 40-50% bonds in your portfolio.
Essentially, by having a higher bond allocation in the five years leading up to retirement and the first 10 or 15 years of retirement, you are being extremely conservative and defensive and trying to protect the value of your portfolio from significant decline due to a very bad market year.
3. Using fixed or dynamic withdrawal rules
As I demonstrated above, two out of three retirees are better off when withdrawing only 4% from end-of-year portfolio value rather than starting at 4% withdrawal then increasing by 3% each year to account for inflation.
Another withdrawal method would be using a dynamic withdrawal rate. Basically, spend more in good years and spend less in bad years. So withdrawing a higher percentage in good years (like 4-5%) and a lower percentage in bad years (like 2-3%) could be a good idea.
4. Utilizing dividend income
For the most part, this is what we’re planning to do. We plan to live off dividend income and not touch our capital regardless of the market performance.
This, of course, assumes that the dividend income continues to grow organically and we don’t encounter significant dividend cuts.
5. Having flexible income
If you encounter a few years of poor market returns, one strategy is to pick up some part-time income for a few years to reduce the income dependency on your investment portfolio. This is what many FIRE folks are doing and what Mark from My Own Advisor talked about in his guest appearance on DIY Wealth Canada.
6. Buy an annuity
Buying an annuity means you will get steady payments in retirement, which should reduce the income dependency on your investment portfolio.
An annuity will give you steady cash flow for life so you can sleep easy at night. Furthermore, some annuities are adjusted for inflation so your real purchasing power does not erode due to inflation.
7. Asset allocation
Rather than being 100% in equities in retirement, you may want to consider having a certain percentage of your portfolio in bonds or other fixed income.
8. Reduce your cost of living by spending time abroad
The lower your expenses are, the smaller your withdrawals need to be. One way to reduce your cost of living is to live or spend time in low-cost countries rather than Canada. For example, you can spend time in Southeast Asia or Eastern Europe for three months to reduce your expenses.
As mentioned in my ” The Uncomfortable Middle ” article, we are financially independent on paper but not ready to step into the early retirement phase yet. Sure, some of my hesitation has to do with identity and purpose. But the biggest reason preventing us from stopping full employment and starting early retirement is my concerns with sequence of returns risk. We want to build up sufficient buffers to reduce this risk.
So what’s our plan exactly?
In addition to putting money aside in our Long Terms Savings for Spending (LTSS) account each month, we are working on building a cash buffer in our investment portfolio by stopping dripping in RRSPs and non-registered accounts.
Our plan of living off dividends should provide some margin of safety as well (so we don’t have to withdraw 4% from our portfolio; a smaller withdrawal percentage, if needed, should be much safer).
Having a part-time income or generating income via our side businesses (i.e. this blog) should also help, even if the income is very small.
Summary – Sequence of returns risk
Sequence of returns risk is real and is not something you can eliminate. The market will remain emotional over the short term and will continue to behave irrationally due to news, geopolitical tensions, wars, and other various factors.
But retirees can certainly protect themselves and reduce the sequence of returns risk by building flexibility, buffers, and diversification in their retirement plans. Hopefully this would mean a few bad market years become a survivable inconvenience rather than a complete disaster.
This article turned out to be MUCH LONGER than I planned. My key takeaway?
- Don’t assume the “average” return will show up in retirement. Average return is over a long-term period. The yearly performance will vary. Plan for that and do consider different sequences of returns in your retirement planning.
- Focus on the first 10 years of retirement. Very bad returns in the first 10 years (especially the first three years) will cause significant heartache for you and may mean you will run out of money.
- Building multiple hedges rather than only relying on one. This may mean using a cash buffer plus dividend plus part-time income plus a dynamic withdrawal rate.
For readers who have retired or are close to retirement, how are you thinking about sequence of return risk in your own plan? I’d love to hear from you.